MILTHORPE MUSEUM ACCOUNT OF THE GOLD DISCOVERY AT OPHIR
In March 1851 John Lister and William and James Tom discovered payable gold at Summer Hill Creek, which came to be known as Ophir.
Although not recognised as such until 40 years later, these young men were part of the catalyst for the first gold rush seen in New South Wales and the beginning of great change in the colonies that were becoming known as Australia.
The story that Edward Hargraves discovered gold persists to this day and will no doubt continue, although the NSW Legislative Assembly Select Committee overturned the accepted version in December 1890. The Report states that ‘Messrs Tom [William and James] and Lister were undoubtedly the first discoverers of gold in Australia of payable quantity.’
John H A Lister along with William Jnr and James Tom became partners with Edward Hargraves in the search for payable gold in March 1851.
Initially finding some colour, Hargraves left despondent while the others continued to work the area around Summer Hill Creek. Lister and the Toms found what amounted to 4oz, an amount considered to be viable for prospecting. This information was sent to Hargraves who, upon receipt announced through the papers that gold had been discovered.
Hargraves neglected to mention his partners in the endeavour. The NSW Government, which had offered a £10,000 reward for the discovery of payable gold in Australia, paid Hargraves his reward and eventually a pension. William Tom Jnr began lobbying the Government in 1853
The government approved £1000 for the three partners. This is the only reward ever received by them. The Select Committee in its 1891 report acknowledged that the three claimants did discover the first payable gold and not Edward Hargraves.
It seems that it was too difficult for the NSW Legislative Council to fully rescind the Hargraves’ claim, even after the findings of the 1890 Select Committee. It is a sad irony that John Lister died on the day he was to give evidence to the commission and that the discoverers never did see any more money than the one thousand pounds. This has been a contested moment in the history of New South Wales.
Hargraves was persistent in his quest to be known as the discoverer of the first payable gold in Australia, petitioning the Victorian Government for the full payment of their reward after the government had decided to pay him only £2938, instead of the full £5000 originally offered.
James Tom was in Victoria at the time of Hargraves’ claim to the Victorian Government and it was through James Tom counter claim that the reward was paid only in part.
The collection of objects pertaining to John Hardman Australia Lister and William Tom Junior, although not vast, is of national significance because it is all that remains of these largely unrecognised men involved in a crucial event in Australian history.
The collection at Milthorpe Golden Memories Museum includes examples of William Tom’s and John Hardman Australia Lister’s signatures on legal documents and personal belongings, including a gold fossicking pick. Millthorpe cemetery is the burial site for John H A Lister while William Tom Jnr is buried at Byng.
Together this collection will provide a strong basis for interpretation on the discovery of gold in NSW and its subsequent momentous effects on the economic and cultural development of the colonies.
The area around Millthorpe is still involved with the mining of gold at Cadia Mine.
Research by Elaine Kaldy copyrights belong to Golden Memories Museum Millthorpe