The Lambing Flat riots
To understand the Lambing Flat riots, you really need to understand the overall context within which the new goldfield developed.
Exactly what was it about the new field at Lambing Flat that set it apart from those numerous big new discoveries that had gone before? Just why was the mood of that time so keen seize upon the new alluvial goldfield?
Well – the fact was that the easily won gold that had set Victoria apart from all others was giving out and, as one correspondent reported “Should the decrease continue at this rate for a few years, diggers – that is, men working alluvial claims – will become a rarity, and gold digging will become what it eventually must, a question of machinery and wages.”
25th September 1860
In this environment, the news that emerged at the start of spring in 1860 of an exciting new find at Lambing Flat in south west NSW was sure to get the attention of a wide audience.
25th September 1860
The diggers continue to find new ground every day, and it is expected that the richest part of the neighbourhood has not yet been struck.
Provisions are cheap and pro- curable in abundance. Additions to the population are occurring every day; the greater part of the arrivals being from the Bathurst country.
There are a great many Chinese on the ground, and the labour being light, this place, is likely to become a favourite with them.
It is much to be desired that the Execu- tive would proclaim Lambing Flat a gold-field, as then the gold-mining regulations would be brought into operation, and persons would go to work in con- structing dams and cutting races.
But at the present time, as there is no protection, and therefore no en- couragement for such laborious undertakings, the diggers are only scratching about, and not turning the ground to its most profitable use.
Several miners who have tried the place are of this opinion, and state ‘ that were it proclaimed they would remain. We have no doubt that Mr. Commissioner Beckham, who is anxious to promote the interests of the diggers, will urge the Government to take the necessary step. Gold here is worth £3 15s. an ounce.- Yass Courier.
8th October 1858
By October 1860, Lambing Flat was really beginning to make a stir with one pundit predicting it would produce more gold than any other goldfield in NSW.
Small wonder then that people were really starting to stream in. Significantly fears were already being expressed about the general lack of water however, and it was the absence of this precious resource that would help fuel tensions on the field.
8th October 1858
A correspondant writes :It is our impression that the country at and around Lambing Flat will produce more gold than any other goldfield in New South Wales
The opinion that there will not bo a sufficiency 01 water I« rc_| absurd. Those who have seen the richest gold-fields lu Victo.il and New South Wales muBt recollcot that previous to their bd’4 worled there was no oppcaranco of water oa uj of them, and that when they were worked then was always an abundance, if not superabundance Ii only requires a thousand perrons to comu on this M and work It properly, and then we shall not hear any eomplii« about a want of water.
LAMMING FLAT DIGGINGS.-
Mr. Elijah Howard of Tumut has returned from a brief visit to these diggings, and altogether reports favourably of them. He considers there is about 1500 persons at work there, whose success is more or less great.
It is his impresslon that the field will be workable during the entire summer with a little economy with respect to the water.
There are a good many earning from £3 to £5 a week per man, some of course tiding lees, as on all other gold fields, and some doing more. The diggers were demanding £3 an ounce for thoir gold in hand, which he believed must amount fullv to 1000 ounces, but no buyers to any extent at that price.
On Monday last there was a rush to the head of Spring Creek ; the first hole sunk there produced a prospect of IS dwts. The following lottcr has been rcoolved from o townsman .
“Laming Flat, September JO.-I arrived on these diggings last Tuesday, and I have not as yet tinned to, but have spcnt my time overlooking tho work of others this week, the diggings are not what people supposed them to be , but there is one thing in their favour, it is such a splendid-looking auriferous country for miles around.
There are a great number of diggers flocking here every day.There are now upward of a thousand people on the mines.
Wc have no commissioner at present. The sinking in Chance Gully is frcm six- to ten feet, and in other parts from twenty to twenty-live feet.
The avorage yield is from about one to three pennyweights of gold I per tub. Tho gold is very fine and scaley, and fetches £3 14». per ounce. There are nothing but cradles and I dishes used here, which causes a deal of this kind of gold to be ‘ wasted.
The water is too muddy and scarce for sluching. The diggers ore all of opinion that it would pay well if thorc was plenty of water.
In my opirlon the water in Chance Gully, if wo have not rain occasionally, will be due up in a months timo.
There ure often new rushes from one place to another. A quartz reef has been struck on the ri60 of the hill from ClianceGullv, and c1 uni all around it were taken up immediately , I had a look at the quariz, and it shews well; you can sec the gold, which is quite visible in it.
These diggings extends for miles round, and it is supposed that something very remunerative will turn up after a while. The avcrago earnings arc from £1 to £1 per man.
27th October 1860
Also noted in this report was the fact that “In New South Wales, the last few years show so considerable an increase in the yield of gold, with almost an absence of machinery, the average earnings per man being far above the Victorian diggers, it is not very surprising under these circumstances that there are thousands of diggers in Victoria at the present time eager to get to New South Wales.”
27th October 1860
I will give a short account of the present state of the Victorian gold fields which, perhaps, may interest some of your readers, and in a measure prove that “ all that glitters is not gold.”
During the last few years I have been to the majority of rushes that have taken place in Victoria and have had an opportunity of seeing the condition of the gold-diggers.
As a class, I have no hesitation in saying that they are the poorest in the colonie… they are the hardest working and the worst paid; and, I believe, if it was anything but gold they were looking, for that not one-half of the present mining population could exist, for it is the talismanic sound of gold that keeps thousands working in the vain hope that one day they will get sufficient to repay for all.
Gold-digging in Victoria during tho last few years is very different to what it was previously.
It is now a question of machinery and large working companies. Not of rich ground, when quartz will pay at half an ounce to the ton. Companys crushing and amalga- mating for the public at 10s. per ton, hundreds of puddling machines working and paying wages out of dirt that averages from one-half to one penny- weight to the load.
It will be seen that what a digger calls a pitchhole, is a very rare occurrence. Yet with all the amount of machinery and the increase of population, the gold-fields ot Victoria since 1856 show a very great decrease, and this year in particular -for it was expected with the companies that were so quickly formed some time since, whose shares were Eo eagerly taken up, the introduction of such an amount of machinery, that the yield of 1860 would at ihe least equal 1859 ; but up to the present date it falls very far short-a decrease of upwards of 5000 ounces weekly.
Should tie decrease continue at this rate for a few years, diggers-that is, men working alluvial claims-will become a rarity, and gold digging will become what it eventually must (for every year proves it), a question of machinery and wages.
And much as I may be opposed to the system myself, I think that the settlement of large populations in the interior so engaged will be far more beneficial to the colonieB than the roving habits and misery entailed upon a very large proportion of the gold-diggers of the present day.
In New South Wales the last few years show so considerable an increase in the yield of gold, with almost an absence of machinery, the average earn- ings per man being far above the Victorian diggers it is not very surprising under these circumstances that there are thousands of diggers in Victoria at «ho present time eager to get to New South Wales ; and whether Kiandra tums out a payable field or other, wise, there are thousands that will never return to Victoria, but will try some of the older fields ; for it is n singular fact that, with all the excitement with respect to Kiandra, the other fields still keep up their returns, and it behoves the Govcrrmênt of New South Wales to give every assistance in their power, so far as information is con’ceihed, und so endeavour-to keep^ a laTge pro – portion of the population that certainly will flow into New South Walts in the course of the next few months. Trusting there is nothing in this letter that will in- duce “any one to turn gold-digger, or make to the Snowv River.
7th February 1861
As a speech given at Lambing Flat early the following year was to explain however, the general state of NSW goldfields was poor … “instance Kiandra, Araluen, Turon, Meroo, Tambaroora, &c., in short, gentlemen, they are all in a state of insolvency and the only solvent one is the one on which we are striving for an honest livelihood.”
7th February 1861
We are now, I may safely say, on the only gold-field in New south Wales which has the appearance of being a permanent one — the only one on which the hard-working miner (the mainstay of the colony can eke out more than a bare subsistance. (Hear, hear.)
You are, no doubt, aware of the state the other gold-fields are in — instance Kiandra, Araluen, Turon, Meroo, Tambaroora, &c., in short, gentlemen, they are all in a state of insolvency, and the only solvent one is the one on which we are striving for an honest livelihood.
(Hear, hear.) Now the livelihood is about to be torn from your grasp; but how, and by whom! By the Curse the plague of the country, namely Chinamen. (Shouts of “Never. never; down with them.” I am certain that the Burrangorang gold- fields will be a diggings for years, capable of supporting thou- sands upon thousands of poor men. (Hear, hear.)
But how long will they continue to be the support of thousands who have no other way of gaining homes: livelihood but by begging, if the Chinese are allowed to pour in upon us in such countless numbers. Why, six months will smother them.
What, tben, are they to do! Where are they to go! God help the poor men who have wives and families depending on them for support at such a time.
Well, I will answer,—why, starve (Great uproar, and execrations at the Chinamen.) Mr. Stewart then in a humorous vein sug- gested a remedy, by telling them if they were good working men they might obtain seven or ten shillings per week from the squatter, with rations,—which produced a tumult of hisses, groans, and anything but flattering exclamations. In conclusion, he said—It doesn’t require second sight to see into the future.
It is quite evident to all what the result will be if we do not take some measure to stop this gross outrage upon our rights. (Hear.) Then, men and fellow-miners, let us assert our rights before God and man—in the clear face of day—like free-born Britons and prevent ourselves from being trampled to the dust like dogs. (Great confusion.)
But, gentlemen, I would strongly advise you to keep within the bounds of the law and not commit a breach of the peace. (Cheers from the Commissioner and numbers In the crowd.) Mr. Stewart then read the following resolution:— Since the Government will not protect us, ourselves, families, society, and necessary occupations from the incursions of a race of savages, we bind ourselves, to a man, to do so: and for that pur- pose we intend to give all Chinese or descendants of that race two days notice to quit the Burrangong gold-fields; and in the event of their not complying with that request, to take such measures as shall satisfactorily rid the mining community of the Barran- gong for ever of pests and nuisances.”.
Amidst the greatest excitement and confusion a respectable miner named Dayton seconded the resolution. Several other speakers endeavoured to be heard, but an over- powering majority were for instant action, and “no notice” was the general cry.
With the general state of alluvial mining on the NSW fields being sluggish, it’s easy to see why the rich prospects of the Lambing Flat field excited such attention.
This at the very time when the future viability of the self employed, small scale alluvial miner was being questioned amidst the likelihood of NSW following Victoria down the path of independent diggers becoming a mere labour force to further the interests of mining companies.
Passionate stuff this and any wonder that when one threw in the vexed issues of the Chinese presence on the new fields, people seized upon it as the pivotal issue around which to condense a broader sense of ‘they dun me wrong’. This in turn ushered in a very tragic ten month period on the new Lambing Flat field as the first racial riots erupted there at the start of summer 1860.
18th December 1860
The first news of a major incident at Lambing Flat broke in the Sydney media just prior to Christmas.
18th December 1860
INFORMATION was brought to Yass on last Wednesday forenoon that some of the European population on Lambing Flat, after the occurrences of Sunday last, as reported in our last issue, attacked a party of Chinese, and maltreated them to such an extent as to cause the death of at least one of their number.
Some reports say two of the Chinese were killed. We are informed that the “ tails “ of the unfortunate Celestials were cut off in so barbarous a manner as to detach the skin from the back of the head ; and further, that the brutality was carried to the length of cutting the ears off of several. We can scarcely give the reports credence, and sincerely hope, for the reputation of the miners on Lambing Flat, that the whole statement is unfounded ; but the particulars have been repeated to us by two or three respectable persons, and hence our giving it publicity. It is certainly to be regretted that the Government have been so laggard in afford- ing needful protection to life and property on the diggings, the sole staff, only very recently appointed, consisting of a Commissioner and two mounted troopers, who are stationed some twelve miles distant from the locality where mining operations are carried on.
RUMOURED ATTACK ON THE CHINESE ONE OR TWO KILLED.
INFORMATION was brought to Yass on last Wednes- day forenoon that some of the European population on Lambing Flat, after the occurrences of Sunday last, as reported in our last issue, attacked a party of Chinese, and maltreated them to such an extent as to cause the death of at least one of their number.
Some reports say two of the Chinese were killed. We are informed that the ” tails ” of the unfortunate Celestials were cut off in so barbarous a manner as to detach the skin from the back of the head ; and further, that the brutality was carried to the length of cutting the ears off of several.
We can scarcely give the reports credence, and sincerely hope, for the reputation of the miners on Lambing Flat, that the whole statement is unfounded ; but the particulars have been repeated to us by two or three respectable persons, and hence our giving it publicity.
It is certainly to be regretted that the Government have been so laggard in afford- ing needful protection to life and property on the diggings, the sole staff, only very recently appointed, consisting of a Commissioner and two mounted troopers, who are stationed some twelve miles distant from the locality where mining operations are carried on.
22nd December 1860
Significantly it was soon followed up by a series of reports from Yass questioning the veracity of the claims. It was noted that “one Chinaman lost his life from the buffeting he received. Some others had their pigtails cut off, and were somewhat injured, but there does not appear to have been any premeditation in the affair.”
Maybe – maybe not. The Yass Courier was after all noted for its partisan support of the miners. Certainly come the new year and further disturbances there was no doubting the premeditation evident in the attacks on Chinese.
22nd December 1860
The news from the diggings fines onr last is of the same favou-ttblo oboraoter as that formerly reported. The miners ara steady at work, and meet with a satisfactory reward for tbeir labour?.
Heavy finds and hngo nuggets are not the “ order of the day” at Ibu Lambing Flat, but with a certain and a fair return for tboir labour, the’diggers aro earnestly and continually at work, and the only dissatisfaction which exists ia at the Government for having hitherto ignored their neoesslties in the way of police protection and poalal communica- tion.
Tho reported rfinturbaocea eei m at last to have caused a little aotlvity amongst tho authorities, SR Captain Zouch and six mounted troopers left Yass laBt Monday morning for the diggings. “With a population of between three and four tbouaand persons on the ground, it is- surprising tbat no stepB bavo yet been taken to secure the regular and frequent delivery of letters, and we ‘ hope the Poslma-ter-General will see tho necessity of at once bestiriing himself lo bave Ibis very neoei-sary right ex- tended to the digging population on the Lnmbing Flat.
Some short time since, Mr. J. Garry annonnoed his in- tention to rnn a ooaob twice a.woek from Binalong, via Marrnmburrah, to the Lambing Fiat ; and two other oonviyanees ‘ are advertised to rnn from Burrowa, via Marengo, to tho diggings, a’so twioe a-week.
With three conveyances on the. road, we oannot tbink that the ex- pense of having the mails regularly oonveyed to the Lambing Flat can be any consideration, and we sincerely hope that this matter will be at onoa atlended to.
Doubts still exist aa to the truthfulness of Hie re- ported murder of the two Chinamen. Two gentlemen who left the diggings on Sunday last, state that tbey beard nothing of tbe ooourrtnee while on the field, and are disinclined to believe the statement.
Others ‘lately re tnrned admit having heard a rumour to that effect, but ara not’prepared to vouch for its trutbfnlneaB. Probably the mail due to-morrow (Thursday) will put us in poa soasion of our correspondent’s letter, and enable us au-Fix this text thoritatively to oantradlot or confirm tbe report.
The Yass Courier of Saturday last atates that the former reports as to the riots at Lambing Flat and the murder of two Chinamen, &c.,were’exaggerated. It add» that on the evening of the day on which the Bparring saloons were destroyed by the Vigilance Committee and their owners driven off the diggings, the mob fell across some Chinese, who certainly received more kicks than half-pence.
Tnoy got knocked about a good deal, and one Chinaman lost his life from the buffet» he received. Some other» had their pigtail» cut off, and were somewhat injured, but there does not apnear to have been any premedi- tation in the affair. “It is singular that, although it wa» known that the Chinaman had come by hi» death by violence, no coroner’» inquest or magisterial inquiry was held on the body.
When the Lambing Flat diggings were proclaimed as a goldfield on 27 November 1860 they were given the name Burrangong after a local creek.
In the absence of any effective police force the new diggings were a fertile field for brigands such that a miners protection league was formed to look after the more sober elements of the community.
This protection league which seems to have started out as a genuine community endeavour to assist in the stabilisation of the field was quickly hijacked by extremist views to become a mobilising force of anti-Chinese activism.
It was at one of the group’s public meetings on Sunday 27 January attended by around 1500 of the field’s 8000 European miners that what started out as call for concerted political action degenerated into a riot leading to forcible expulsion of the estimated 1500 Chinese from the field.
Many of these then took refuge on the Currawong Station of James Roberts some 20km to the south east near Murrumburrah.
3rd February 1861
A detailed account of the events of that day was published soon after in the “Lambing Flat Miner”.
Not surprisingly the field’s very own newspaper gives a highly sanitised and understanding view of what transpired. Its attention to detail however makes for an absorbing account.
3rd February 1861
It having become rumoured amongst the mining-community on the Burrangong for some time past that the Chinese intended assembling on that gold-field, all armed, and in such numbers that they could make a determined stand against any European force that could reasonably be brought against them, and that their intention was to make it a Chinese territory, several respectable miners issued a notice calling for a meeting on Sunday last, to take into their serious consideration the best means of nipping the Mongolians’ friendly intentions in the bud.
Such a gathering has scarcely been seen in these colonies assembled on Sunday afternoon, near the Golden Point, Lambing Flat, fully determinad to settle the matter then and forever.
The meeting was originally announced for twelve o’clock, and before that time several hundreds had scattered themselves round Golden Point, discussing the probable results of their movement.
Owing to the impossibility of their friends at Stoney Creek to arrive by that hour, a postponement to three in the afternoon was found necessary, and during the interval the majority re- paired to their abode for refreshment.
About two o’clock a large body came in from Stoney Creek, headed by a brass band playing martial airs, with the Union Jack on either side floating over them.
They came on horseback, on foot, and in vehicles, and the band occupied a “jaunting car” drawn by two-fine horses, with a digger acting as John. The only arms they appeared to have were sticks looking in many instances like shovel and pick handles, which were flourished more or less as the shouts of the Lambing Flat men greeted them.
Soon after, a party from Spring Creek; was led up the main street by a fine burly young fellow carrying the Union Jack, and by another beating a drum made out of a tin case, whose shouts gathered along with them all stragglers.
The arrival of this last party was the signal for busi- ness. By this time there could not have been less than fifteen hun- dred men on the ground; but so orderly and determined were they to preserve peace, that not a solitary breach occurred.
Several boxes were placed together on a small hillock, with the Union Jacks on either side of them form a platform around which the dense assemblage collected, the Commissioner, with his seven troopers, all well armed, with detectives Carnes and Scarlett, occupying a position a short distance away.
The band opened the proceedings by playing a martial air, after which Mr. Charles Allen, storekeaper, of Lambing Flat, was universally appointed chairman. Who read the following notice convening the meeting :—
Notice.—A public meeting will be held on Sunday, the 27th instant, at ten o’clock. in the vicinity of Golden Point, Lambing Flat, for the purpose of taking into consideration whether Burrangong is an European gold field or a Chinese territory.
A numerous attendance is requested. He then alluded to the good order always maintained by the diggers in their movements, and hoped that day’s proceedings would be no libel on their past conduct. The aasault on the shanties and gambling homes, he said, was a sufficient guarantee that they only desired a good state of society, and their previous affair with the Chinese was proof that they only wished to be rid, as peaceably as possible, of a nuisance to them all.
Should any breach of the peace occur, he would be the first man to aid the Commissioner and his staff in quelling it, and he was confident that the originators of the movement would do the same. (Cheers from the Commissioner.)
He then introduced Mr. Stewart, who would address them, and claimed for him a quiet and impartial hearing. Mr. Stewart on coming forward, waa assailed by a perfect volley of cheers. He said—Mr. Chairman, gentlemen, and fellow miners,—Before I go into the business for which we have met, I wish to state that had it not been for some treachery on the part of a person unknown to me, who pulled our notice down, we should have had six times the gathering here to day.
(A voice—”It was the Commissioner,” and loud cries of “There he is.” Commissioner or no Commissioner, it was an uncon- stitutional act, but it matters little now since we are sufficiently numerous to do what we want to do. (Vehement cheering.)
Well, Mr. Chairman, gentlemen, and fellow-miners.—A meeting has been called this day—and proud I am to see you have to nobly respond to it.(Hear, hear.) We have assembled for the purpose of discussing a very important and serious question. (Loud applause.)
I presume you are all aware what that question is. (Cries of “Yes, yes; go on.”) The question is— shall the Burrangong Gold-Field (as you have no doubt seen on the notice) become a Chinese territory or an European diggings. (Shouts of a European diggings” and “Down with the pig- tails”)
The question is really becoming so serious that it is now intolerable. (Hear, hear.) To my own certain knowledge there cannot be less than fifteen or sixteen hundred on the Lambing Flat and its vicinity, and the greater number, if not all of them, have arrived within the last fortnight.
(Cries of “Down with them.”) I also have it from reliable authority, that the Chinese are on the road to these diggings in thousands. (Cries of “Stop them,” “turn them back.”) N
ow, gentlemen, shall the Chinese monopolise the gold-field that we have prospected and deve- loped! (Cries of “No, no;” “down with them,” — and shall we as men and British subjects stand tamely by and allow the bread to be plucked from the mouths of ourselves, our wives, and children by those pig-tailed, moon-faced barbarians.
(Shouts of “Down wilh the pig-tails,” “drive them before us,” —men who would not spend one farthing in the colony could they possibbly avoid it!—men, did I say—oh, my prophetic soul, my comrades—monkeys I ought to have said. (Laughter and cheers.)
No, gentlemen. Were it possible for them to get what they daily consume from China, and to be able to avoid all con- nexion with British or foreign traffic, they would glory in being able to do so. (Cheers.)
Now, gentlemen, you see what they expend in the colony, and the benefit derived from them is compulsory, which plainly signifies that they cannot help them- selves. (Hear, hear.)
It is a well-known fact that not one Chinaman out of five thousand, when he accumulates what he considers a sufficiency in his own country, but verifies the words of a well-known song written by the celebrated Charles Thatcher-— “And blow’em, I say; scores arrive every day, Get all they can, then hook it away.”—(Cheers.) And these are the beings whom the Government class as the companions of civilised Christians (Cries of “ We won’t have them.”)
These are the beings who, in a court of justice, are allowed to rank side by side with the European whose life, before to-day, has trembled in the balance of one of these miscreant’s oaths. (Shouts of “Away with the wretches.”) Oh! horrible mockery—disgrace to the British Constitution—on the oath of one of these miscreants—now, gentlemen, keep your ears open)—this oath that a Christian’s life may be as affected by, is neither more nor less than cutting cock’s head off, breaking a saucer, or blowing a match out after it is lit, which is now proved to be a complete piece of humbug in their own country. (Vehement cheering and cries of “Shame.”)
So you see you have got nothing but a Chinaman’s word against a Christian’s oath in a court of justice. (Cries of “Shame, shame.” and “Away with the pig-tails”)
We are now, I may safely say, on the only gold-field in New south Wales which has the appearance of being a permanent one—the only one on which the hard-working miner (the mainstay of the colony can eke out more than a bare subsistance. (Hear, hear.)
You are, no doubt, aware of the state the other gold-fields are in —instance Kiandra, Araluen, Turon, Meroo, Tambaroora, &c., in short, gentlemen, they are all in a state of insolvency, and the only solvent one is the one on which we are striving for an honest livelihood. (Hear, hear.) Now the livelihood is about to be torn from your grasp; but how, and by whom! By the Curse the plague of the country, namely Chinamen. (Shouts of “Never. never; down with them.”
I am certain that the Burrangorang gold- fields will be a diggings for years, capable of supporting thou- sands upon thousands of poor men. (Hear, hear.) But how long will they continue to be the support of thousands who have no other way of gaining homes: livelihood but by begging, if the Chinese are allowed to pour in upon us in such countless numbers. Why, six months will smother them. What, tben, are they to do! Where are they to go! God help the poor men who have wives and families depending on them for support at such a time.
Well, I will answer,—why, starve (Great uproar, and execrations at the Chinamen.) Mr. Stewart then in a humorous vein sug- gested a remedy, by telling them if they were good working men they might obtain seven or ten shillings per week from the squatter, with rations,—which produced a tumult of hisses, groans, and anything but flattering exclamations.
In conclusion, he said—It doesn’t require second sight to see into the future. It is quite evident to all what the result will be if we do not take some measure to stop this gross outrage upon our rights. (Hear.) Then, men and fellow-miners, let us assert our rights before God and man—in the clear face of day—like free-born Britons and prevent ourselves from being trampled to the dust like dogs. (Great confusion.)
But, gentlemen, I would strongly advise you to keep within the bounds of the law and not commit a breach of the peace. (Cheers from the Commissioner and numbers In the crowd.) Mr. Stewart then read the following resolution:— Since the Government will not protect us, ourselves, families, society, and necessary occupations from the incursions of a race of savages, we bind ourselves, to a man, to do so: and for that pur- pose we intend to give all Chinese or descendants of that race two days notice to quit the Burrangong gold-fields; and in the event of their not complying with that request, to take such measures as shall satisfactorily rid the mining community of the Barran- gong for ever of pests and nuisances.”.
Amidst the greatest excitement and confusion a respectable miner named Dayton seconded the resolution. Several other speakers endeavoured to be heard, but an over- powering majority were for instant action, and “no notice” was the general cry.
Groups collected, and all tried to speak at once, when the band, striking up, and moving slowly away, was the signal for the breaking up of the meeting, and on the gathering rolled in one heavy cloud in the direction of Little Spring Creek, alternately harangued and cautioned by the Commissioner and the sergeant against using violence, and the crowd promising, in the event of such taking place, to apprehend the delinquents.
As one man expressed it, “We only want to sweep them before us like chaff before the wind: “and so tbey did. Scouts imme- diately started up the creek and in every direction; and arriving at the destination, a sight that baffles description presented itself. On the opposite side of the creek one or two tents were in flames, which was generally believed to have been the work of the Chinese themselves.
Along the bed of the creek one mass of celestial life seemed to agitate it with all the marks of haste in its movements, carrying such burdens that even Chinamen might grew weary with. The banks on either side were lined with Europeans who hurried China’s brown sons on by occaaional remarks and strong intima- tions, the band playing the whole time. Up the steep on to the flat they came like the flowings of a never-ceasing river.
Not leas than from two to three thousand came up in single file and marched along silently in the direction the Europeans pointed out. One sick Chinaman was found, who was permitted to remain, with one of his countrymen to attend him, and one of the best huts offered as a residence. When the others had all cleared out of the creek, the band turned the tide in the direction of the township, through which they escorted the whole of the Mongolians till they came on to Blackguard Gully, where a similar scene was gone through.
Here a tent or two was burned, and another sick Chinaman protected, and the whole mass drifted away from the diggings according to the directions given by the Europeans, who shortly after returned to the Flat, when the proceedings were supposed to have terminated.
Late in the afternoon, a cry fluttered over the Lambing Flat that Stewart, the speaker of the previous meeting, was appre- hended. It did not require a second summons to bring the lin- gering and self-satisfied agitators alongside the court-house.
It was like the rise of a slumbering volcano. Although the Stoney Creek party had mostly left the place, there was sufficient left from the embers of the late affair to raise a blaze to the name of Stewart.
But, fortunately for society and everything else on Lambing Flat, it turned out to be a kind of a “bye-ball” of the name of Smith, who had certainly proved himself rather uproarious in the great event of the day. But the crowd were not to be disappointed.
They had come for the release of their best man, and they found it an inferior one. But as they had pledged themselves to live or fall by the sacrifices made by any man in that days proceedings, so they felt, so long as he was attached to them, he was bound to receive their support.
At whoevers instigation the man was arrested, under the circumstances, it was condemnable. The whole proceedings had passed off without a solitary breach, and for Government officials to be the first to do anything to create that breach was, to say the least, censorious.
All Government officials, and all men who love law and order would have been justified in taking any step to quell a threatened disturbance of the peace, but no man is justified, let him be Governor himself, in raising a storm that has for a certainty lulled. We will veil the after proceedings, and conclude the affair by stating that the man was let loose on respectable bail, and bound over the following day to keep the peace—a proceeding which might have been adopted when the excitement had died away with much better effect, if necessary.
21st February 1861
Nor was this the end of the matter. As some Chinese drifted back to the field, additional riots broke out to drive them away.
21st February 1861
Tuesday morning about midday, some forty Europeans assembled at Blackguard Gully and drove off soma 201 Chinese, burning several tents, blankets, and goods.
The Chinese resisted the attack, but were obliged to surrender. Three Chinamen were maltreated and one seriously injured on the head.
They were robbed of their picks, shovel», and cradles and other good!, , which were carried oil’ hy some Europeans. C
aptain Zouch, Mr. Chief Commissioner (îloete, Mr. Commitsioner Dickson, and Mr. Inspector Single- ton, «willi six foot police, proceeded to the spot, and arrested fifteen men, who were immediately marched to the camp, end an oxaniinatiaa opened.
The Chinese evidence wa« very unsatisfactory, and in consequence the Court was adjourned till thi» morn- ing, the prisoners being ali admitted to bail ia one surety of £»0 each.
Scouts were then sent out to Stoney Creek mi Spring Creek, to bring the st hole body of miner*. Sion twter ten o’clock last night, nearly 4800 men lud aftembled, many of whom «ere under arm«.
They conttnuid shouting and pesambxlating the town the whole night, frequently firing volley». They were occasionally harangued by the leader» «f _ the Miners’ League, who, to some estent, quelled the excitement, urging the men to stand fait tul the decision of the court was ascertained.
The troopers under Captain Zouch and the’ foot police tuite Inspector Singleton, remained under arms the whole night. The excitement was beyond description. A large number of men were armed with revolve«, and this morning they were patrolling the streets openly armed with rifles, muskets, bowie knives, and sticks.
This morning the fifteen prisoners were brought up and all discharged, se no »atisfactoty evidence could be brought against them. A complete cessation, of business is the consequence of the riot. The townspeople are engaged in protecting their fro petty. Seine of the minere are sworn to »weep off the Chinese, and for that purpose they are going to Roberts’ station and other encampment».
The present police force is quite insufficient, if the Chinese are to be protected ; and nothing short of 200 or 300 soldiers «iii suffice. The mob are headed by a band, aad a flag flying, and many of the worst characters are amoogst them. The main body of the men were camped for on hour or two during the night, but numbers are patrolling the afreet drinking and shouting.
Unless the Go- vernment take a decisive stand at once there will be bloodshed, for they are sworn to clear the digging» of every Chinaman. Tooday, noon. Another foi ce of about 150 horgeinen, said SOO oat foot, have arrived from Spring and Stoney Creeki,a»vl have just entered the town amid h urah* from the people. The excitement is intense. , There cannot be less than .1 to 6000 people mMCtisf I round the town.
26th February 1861
Analysis of the events soon began to emerge in the Sydney media. As the report here explains the rioters should not be taken as represeentative of the diggers in general.
“On all the old gold-fields there has been an accumulation of men whose career of indolence, blasphemy, drunkenness, and crime, exposes them to the detestation, of all industrious diggers. Thus the opening of a great gold-field is to them a new career. They rush in hundreds and in thousands! to the sphere of fresh operations.”
26th February 1861
They are always “waiting for something to turn up,” and, whether it comes in the shape of a riot or a revolution, they are gratified by a sense of movement in favour of anarchy.
The people of the colony who honestly earn their bread will have nothing in common with them.
The moment a systematic opposition presents itself to law, all sympathy becomes treachery to the community r.t large. We have one task to fulfil-to strengthen the Govern- ment in all efforts to restore order, and to maintain rights.
When this is done, whatever may be the lesson to be derived from the past, it may assume a legislative form, and come before us in the shape of political redress. We are not,! however, to be deceived with respect to the character of those who have originated this disturbance.
To confound them with the digging population, is to defame it. On- all the old gold-fields there has been an accumulation of such men.
Their career of indolence, blasphemy, drunkenness, and crime, exposes them to the detestation, of all indus- trious diggers. They have passed under the eye of the police, and have gone through so many ordeals as to find their movements con- siderably obstructed. Thus the opening of a great gold-field is to them a new career. They rush in hundreds and in thousands!to the sphere of fresh operations.
They are the vendors of ilhcitdrink-the receivers of stolen goods-the plotters of sticking-up and gold robberies-and generally the main strength and stay of all schemes for the demoralization of the people. A popular grie^ance therefore is to them a centre of operation, and assuming the character of reformers they disguise their latent purpose, and ghc something like eclat to their career of crime. Collected about these men are all those who are weak-minded or naturally turbulent, or whose antipathies to, any class provoke them to discontent.
In the presence of such combinan tions when there is no adequate police force the real mining population can only be silent. Perhaps even this refuge is not permitted, but drawn against his will and judgment the peace- able digger is made to assume an appearance of complicity, however desirous he may be for the repression of that outrage which he seems to countenance. It is to be greatly lamented that the Govern- ment was not thoroughly conscious of the origin and ordinary manifestation of these disorders.
The lamentable letter of Mr. ZOUCH, and the toleration it implied, of drawn swords-the riotous demolition , of shanties, and , so forth-was a blunder as dangerous as any ever committed by a public ‘officer. Nor tan we even now account for the pub- lication of such a letter as a justification of Government indifference or as an explanation of a distinct ‘violation of law.
It was at that ‘ time the Government should have awoke to the true “’character of the movement, and at once ‘have placed force sufficient in the hands of’ trustworthy authorities to put down these in- ‘ Burrectionary proceedings. But instead of all this, weeks have elapsed-reports of the most contradictory nature nave been spread-the respectable press has been snubbed-^etatements whlch’at all events were written in good faith have been called in doubt-and the whole thing har) been glossed over until it can no longer be denied, and until now we are compelled to an armed demonstration such as ‘the colony us never hitherto required. , No doubt the position of a Government con- stituted like ours is difficult.
It is necessary for its political inteiests seem to demand-that there should be such manifestations of disorder as to silence the sympathisers and compel the acknowledgment of the necessity for coecion. Looking at it in this point of view, no doubt the Government felt that any energetic movements’would call down upon them the reproaches of their friends. They would be accused of calumniating the honest digger-of yielding to some aristociatic pressure-of pro- voking the very outrage they pretended to sup- press, lhat they should haye felt “this dan« gerous, is perhaps not co much to be reproached as to be lamented. It is the great fault of our system, and will follow us everywhere when Government has to act against disorder and insurrection.
There can be no doubt of what the Government is bound to do-te maintain in their rights all whose rights have been assailed -’to refuse all intercourse’ or compromise with armed men-to take ‘into custody if they have the Ipower, and bring* to justice those who have threatened its administration, or who have been the leaders of the insurrection.
If all this is done, tbVbest reparation perhaps may^be made which the ciicumstances admit of, and the’ lesson will not hereafter be forgotten. This is the business of the Government, and not to philo- sophise about Caucasian dignity or the rights of free-born Englishmen. We have no rights save those which > the law has given, and others are entitled to claim whatever the law^ has allowed.
This must be the rule of the’ Government in its’ executive capacity, “and this alone. While, however, it may be the aim and effort of the Government to put down insurrection, and * while it should forbid its officers to hold ‘ any parley with insurgents, except to receive thejr absolute submission, it’is not the duty of the Government to meet an armed insurrection with inadequate force. – , ,
It is quite possible that neither our soldiers nor constabulary may be in sufficient strength. It would then be the duty’of the Government to warn all British subjects of their danger and to forbid intercourse.
There are’other methods by which insurgents may be reduced than the sword. Their provisions will soon be exhausted. Ihe respectable diggers would feel that their place was no longer with men in arms against the QUEEN, and either the insurgents would meit away or soon be reduced to such numbers as to admit of a gcod account. ‘
It is, perhaps, by such events as these that great practical lessons are given to the colony. Every man who promotes disorder is imposing a burden as well as a danger -upon the country, and increasing the difficulty of subsistence to his neighbours.
These riots will occasion a heavy expense to the public treasury ; and with a declining revenue it will certainly be impos- sible even to look at the question of the aboli- tion of the gold duty for the next twelve months, even1 were it otherwise admissible.
The effect of disorder on the7 gold-fields must be to render . provisions dearer. Although for a time insecurity will induce men to part with provisions for cash at a lower rate, future sup- plies will be arrested, and the cost of risk will finally fall upon the consumer.
Thus, every digger on Lambing Flat will suffer in his cir cums’ances from the disorder which is said to be created in his cause. It is a remarkable fact, that almost, all the tumultuous and riotous proceedings of these colonies hae arisen from the antipathies of race or nation. Five or ,aix years ago, for instance, the Irish were denounced at Victoria, and wherever an Irishman was seen on the diggings he was hunted with fero- cious pertinacity by a population, to a large extent, composed of libirated thieves, but who, of course, c were particularly concerned about the purity of race.
Every one knows the antipathy-amounting to persecution-which arose against the Germans, particularly in Ade- laide, where they are settled in numbers, andaré among the most saving and industrious of the population. The people of this colony will remember the perfect detestation with which all immigrants were regarded-how they could not pass the streets, or go into any public place, without being insulted by the “ real proprietors,” as they deemed themsehes.
Strange as it may now, seem, it was ne* ertheless the fixed doctrine of the original settlers of this country, that it was intended for them and theil children, and that all “jimmigrants,” as the immigrants were called, were interlopers and intruders-the sweeping of workhousesand gaols. So it goes on. The old and new settlers of the colonies the “jimmigrunts” and the “jail grunts” al} the pure blooded races who ha>e made this country their place of meeting, now lovingly set I themselves in antagonism to the Chinese nearly half the human race !
* Some excuse may be made for grossîgnorance, but to find men of position-who pretend to love liberty-who talk sometimes about Christianit)-giving countenance to these prejudices, stimulating them, and embodjing them in distinct propositions ia sad to every consistent friend of humanity and liberty. It was always so. When there were but two men bom into the world the’ youngest was deemed an interloper by his brother, who asserted his right to exclusive occupation by shedding the “intruder’s” blood.
20th February 1861
Other voices though were also raised in vigorous defence of the actions to expel the Chinese from the field.
“I can assure you it was not out of any hatred or jealousy on the part of the diggers [that the Chinese were expelled], but the whole motive was, as I stated, that they consumed, appropriated, and spoiled the water, and that is the only reason that the European population is as determinedly resolved not to tolerate them any longer.”
20th February 1861
To the Editor of the Herald. Sir, Having arrived from the above locality only a day ago, and finding so many foolish and contradictory reports regarding the treatment of the Celestials by the hands of the European population promulgated in town, I hasten without delay to lay before the pnblic, through the medium of your influential organ, a true statement of this all-en- grossing affair.
I sojourned at the above gold-field for nearly three months; I had, therefore, ample opportunity to make myself acquainted with this unpleasant question, and I am very much apprehensive if this matter is not fairly explained and properly investigated, the results might be of a serious character, and destructive to the prosperity and developement of this magnificent gold-field.
It is a great pity that the Press is so unguarded as to propagate infor- mation of a doubtful nature. I will only mention one in- stance in particular, which, if true, must give to the whole affair quite another complexion.
I refer to the account, so industriously by nearly all colonial papers circulated, that the Chinese have been the first discoverers at the Lambing Flat – an assertion I must beg to contradict. It was not the Celestials who opened that field, but a party of Kiandra returned diggers, and after the latter had been there for some time at work the former swarmed there from the surrounding diggings.
This fact is so generally known, and so clearly evident, that it excited no small merriment when this fiction was read at the diggings, and really no one would take the trouble to contradict such a gross fabrication, and I believe there is already one party who intends to claim the reward of the discovery.
It is now abont five months since the Chinese have been, on account of the scarcity of the water, expelled by the Europeans from the Flat; but it seems that they managed to retire again to the land of promise, and that in larger numbers, and were never molested by the diggers till the latter saw themselves compelled out of the same reason, to proscribe them again ; and I can assure you it was not out of any hatred or jealousy on the part of the diggers, but the whole motive was, as I stated, that they consumad, ap- propriated, and spoiled the water, and that is the only reason that the European population is as determinedly re- solved not to tolerate them any longer.
Water was always a scarce commodity at this field, and without that element the richest diggings are of very little avail.
I have no antipathy against the children of the flowery land, nor have I time or inclination to demonstrate the policy of the introduction or expulsion of that people. I leave that to abler pens and wiser heads ; but so much I can say, that if they are permitted to work at their usual mode of operation, the consequence must either be blood- shed or the interruption and abandonment of one of the best gold-fields ever discovered in New South Wales.
I will not excite the unwary with golden visions, but every one who has visited that diggings must confess that it is what we call the poor man’s diggings. Every one who is able and has the will to work can gain his subsistence, and have every week a pound or two, and if has a little success he can make from £5 to £20 a week, and if he is lucky, why, he can make money.
The field is very exten- sive, and has every appearance to be a per- manent one. Sinking is from three to fifty feet. The cost of living is less than 15s. per week, and there are no less than from 8000 to 10,000 diggers, and very little grumbling to be heard.
I do not deny that there are blanks; but if the comfortable clerk forges his steel pen into a pick, the showy counter-jumper his iron yard measure into a shovel, and the flash tailor’s scissors into a spade, and this interesting trio lavish the same ratio of physical strength on their respective imple- ments that they used to bestow on them when they were yet in their origtnal shape, why, sir, they have no business to curse their stars, and blame the gold-field.
But real hardworking men will find the Burangong a thorough good, honest, hard-working, gold-field. I must, therefore, say it would be a great moral wrong that a few hundred pagans should deprive such a large portion of our colonists of their bread. Undoubtedly it is an undeniable fact that the Government, by receiving from the Chinese 10s a year, is pledged to protect them and assist them to be enabled to work, but do ther not owe the same duty to the Europeans also? or how can they carry out that obligation towards the latter, when they force the former upon them ?
Let us suppose that some of these days there will land in our good harbour of Port Jackson several ships loaded with several thousands of Hottentots, and these several thousands of Hottentots will establish themselves to the no small dismay of our citizens in our honest city of Sydney as shop and store keepers, merchants and bankers.
The non-commercial portion of our fellow citizens would perhaps rejoice – opposition is the life of trade, they would say. But, in course of time, our European shopkeepers, &c., discovered that these several thousands of cuuning Hottentots carry on their mode of business on such a system, that it destroys their whole legiti- mate commerce and ruins the security of credit altogether.
I ask you, sir, would our shrewd shopkeepers, &c., submit to be cheated by a parcel of Hottentot rascals, with their oriental resignation – It is the will of Allah ? Why, sir, we would have monster meetings by day and torchlight, petitions witn twohbundred-yard-signature tails, and many an oratorical genius who now, alas, slumbers on the hard bed of obscurity, would rise like a meteor to save his countrymen ; every ship in the harbour would be pressed to take away from our shores this cursed burden.
Hu- manity, which would very likely be a non-shopkeeper, %c would drop a bitter tear of grief, and lament over the wickedness of the age ; and Tolerance, a retired shopkeeper, &c., but invested his capital in the squatting interest, would do ditto ; but their charitable moans and sighs would soon be drowned in the mighty sea of popular indig- nation.
The diggers at the Lambing Flat, who are simil- arly situated, do not wish to go to such extremities,- all that they wish is, that the Celestials should remove to some other diggings, and if the Government undertakes to protect the Chinese, let them remove to some other of our numerous gold-fields, for at the Flat they will never be protected. The diggers are determined to one man not to tolerate them any longer, and why create rios and bloodshed, when all can be amicably settled ? In conclusion, I trust that the authorities in power will listen to moderation. Apologising for monopolising so much of your …. space. I remain, your obedient servant, A. …………… Sydney, February 18th
1st March 1861
Very quickly the issue zoned back in on the overall policy that had resulted in such a major expansion of the Chinese on the NSW goldfields in the first place – the lack of an Chinese immigrant entry tax that made landing in NSW so much more desirable than going to Victoria.
1st March 1861
That New South Wales has held out a premium for the Chinese immigration there can be but little doubt. Victoria a few years since saw the evils attending so large an increase in the Chinese population, and took measures to prevent ‘ it’.. Ten pounds per head was levied upon their arrival, and other measures taken to compel them to contribute to the revenue, so as to pay for the additional expenses caused by them.
When the Chinese were attracted to Victoria, the goldfields of New South Wales were little thought of, population was greatly wanted for the purpose of developing them, and many thought that Chinese, or any other class, so long as they were a producing class, ought not to be expelled, or any measures taken to prevent their coming.
Both New South Wales and South Australia thought to take advantage of these circumstances, and profit by the troubles of Victoria-and so increase their population. The dangers attending the naviga- tion of Guichen Bay soon dispelled any advantage South Australia may have thought to obtain, and Sydney alone waa the only port they could make for so as to evade the ten pound tax.
The arrival of the Jupiter from Hongkong, a few |days since, is an in- stance of this, for while the Chinese are landed here, the greater part of the cargo ia for Melbourne. Nine tenths of the Chinese that have been landed in Sydney, have been with the intention of making to Victoria, but with a new field like Lambing Flat it is only reasonable to expect that they would prefer the shorter distance to making their way to Victoria.
Had any one proposed a tax of ten pounds per head upon all Chinese, to come into operation simul- taneously with the Victorian law, would he have been listened to ?
All kinds of arguments would have been brought to prove that the Chinese were a very industrious, persevering, and desirous population; but now that the same causes tend to place New South Wales in the same position Victoria was in, having a large extent of auriferous ground to be worked, the troubles that were Victoria’s arc now hers-only doubly so, for, independent of the induce- ment held out for immigration from China, there is the large Chinese population in Victoria.
Many thousands at the first chance will now make for the more favoured spot in New South Wales. Having held out these advantages to the Chinese, it is now a question if they should not be withdrawn, and means taken to prevent the influx of so large a proportion of a race that the Europeans as a class are so opposed to, but in doing so we aro clearly bound to protect those already amongst us so long as they respect and con- form to our laws.
The very opponents of the Chinese are the first to call out against class legislation ; but there are cases in which it is required, this I think I shall be enabled to prove is one ; in doing so I shall have to make a few other remarks.
The opponents of the Chinese allege : first, that they interfere with only one class, i.e. gold-diggers ; for no Chinese come here with any other intention that gold-digging, although some few are engaged in other occupations, and that gold-diggings alone know the extent of their annoyance, their dirty habits, the way in which they spoil water, and prevent much ground from being worked except to disadvantage, Secondly.
That the expend no money. Thirdly, That those who are fortunate enough to make any money return with it to China.
With respect to the first objection, I must say that I think if the Chinese were to overrun any trade or occupation to the extent they do the gold diggers’, you would find the particular class affected quite as loud in their complaints, and demanding their exclusion, as the diggers are now. Those that have worked on gold- fields with a large population of Chinese upon them can alone have any idea of the trouble and annoyance they are to the European population.
Should there be a scarcity of water, their way of working is quite enough to exasperate, and would drive many (who per- haps possess more equanimity of temper than gold-dig ers) to extremes. But by adopting good regulations, well carried out, much of this might be avoided.
Let a commissioner or protector be appointed, whose business should be to look after the Chinese. Let their camps be separate and distinct-a certain num- ber being allowed only in one camp.
Let a local court be established ; let the rules and regulations be such that any offence they may be guilty of with respect to digging can be punished with a fine or im- prisonment, and let the commissioner have the power to decide it on the ground without all the circumlocu- tion of law and appeal ; and, above all, let there be some interpreters (Europeans, if possible).
The farce I have seen performed in many police courts, in swearing a Chinaman would disgust anybody, I firmly believe that so far as bind- ing on their conscience that their is scarce one China- man among a hundred who, during the performance of blowing out a match, breaking a saucer* or putting a cock’s head off, but what is laughing in his sleeve at the gullibility of John Bull j and, independent of this, if there are two Chinese interpreters, often the most important evidence will be given contradictory by them.
Perjury they know nothing, and care less for ; duplicity and cunning they are more than a match for any European. I am aware this would | necessarily incur expense, but let the, Chinese pay for it -, letreach be compelled to pay so much per month, quarter, or year for a protection ticket, and see also j thnt they were in possession of them.
If measures something like these were adopted the Chinese diffi- culty would soen be an affair of the past. The second objection that they expend no money can only be advanced by those who know but little of the Chinese on the gold, fields. When Chinamen are | getting gold I do not think there is any class that live better than they do. They certainly do not drink ; but buying vegetables, fowls, ducks, and pork, none of which on any diggings are to be had very cheap, certainly is no proof of their niggardly habits.
On many of the Victorian diggings, the last . I was on in particular, the Chinese, so far as dress was concerned (and of European manufacture) were certainly equal to (any other class. You do not now hear of driving the Chinese off any of the Victorian diggings. On all the older diggings their consumption forms a considerable amount of the storekeepers takings-their earnings generally are so small that all is expended in food and clothing.
I know one of the largest storekeepers in Victoria who told me not six months since that if it was not for the Chinese he might close his stores. In travelling through Victoria when one of these large six-hone American coaches rush pastyouat the rate often miles an hour, you will be surprised to see the number of Chinese passengers.
This certainly does not look as if they had that peculiar propensity of hoarding their money that many are inclined to think. That there has been many tens of thousand ounces of gold obtained in Victoria that would not otherwise have been were it not for the Chinese no one can doubt. ,This must have been some advan- tage.
One objection to the Chinese is- their great numbers on new gold-fields (as at Lambing Flat) ; but even here, after the Europeans have what they called, worked out a considerable extent of ground, I the Chinese will occupy it, and the Chinese difficulty gradually die away, the storekeepers will find that they are good customers, after the ground has been worked out in the opinion of many.
The third objection, although made by many, is scarcely worth noticing-they would drive the Chinese away, that is, all poor ones ; but any one having made money ought to stop and spend it to take it with him to China is unpardonable.
So much for their liberality-let any one ask any ten gold diggers what they would do if they were fortu- nate enough to make an amount of money that would keep them without further work, and I will answer that nine out of them would say they would go home, wherever that might be, and they have a per- fect right to do so if they please, so long as they are not Chinamen.
I do hope the Government will endeavour to set- tle this question with’ as little delay as possible. The general opinion is that a tax ought to be imposed on all Chinese landing. I think the same amount imposed in Victoria ought to be levied here-it would then show that we were no more desirous of their presence than our sister colony, and it would not be holding out, as we are ‘ now, an indirect advantage to their immigration.
It is with great pleasure I see that Mr. Cowper has left Sydney for Lambing Flat. I feel convinced that his presence and advice will do more to conciliate and ‘ assure the diggers than three times the military force now on their way there. Trusting you will find room for these remarks, I remain, &c. JOHN A. HUX.
What though of events on the Burrangong goldfield as this debate played out in general media?
5th March 1861
Cowper arrived at Lambing Flat amidst much speculation as to what the government would do. Especially high on the concern list of the reform league was that the government would use its major military force to return the Chinese to the field.
5th March 1861
A lengthy telegram was received yesterday morning by Mr. Robertson, from Mr. “Cowper, who had arrived at Lambing Flat at half-past seven o’clock on Saturday evening-the exact time at which he calcu- lated on arriving there.
Mr. Cowper’s despatch was dated on Sunday morning, at which time he had not, of course, entered upon the duties connected with his mission to Burrangong.
The comparative order and peacefulness which, since the expulsion of the Chinese, has prevailed on the diggings, was con- tinuing; but the tenor of Mr. Cowper’s communica- tion confirms all the apprehensions which the recent reports from Lambing Flat have excited,-that in the event of the attempt being made to reinstate the Chinese in their claims, a fatal collision between the armed diggers and the troops will be inevitable.
Mr. Cowper states that his health has been much im- pío ved by the journey, and although on Saturday he travelled nearly a hundred miles, he was suffering no inconvenience from fatigue._
The Premier, Mr. Cowper, arrived from Sydney last night. Mr. M’Lerie, assistant superintendent of the Southern patrol, with a’serjeant-mojor and eleven troopets, armed thia day from the Kiandra district.
Mr. Sub-commissioner Lynch, from Tumberumba, is also at the camp. fevetal telcgiaphic clerical ertors have occurred in my telegrams.
The number of persona a tteuded the monster meetings at Stoney and Spring Creeks, re- ported in the Herald, of 19th ultimo, and Sjdney Mail, of 23rd, should have read GOO not 6000 at each.
The amount of gold in Herald of 20th ultimo, should have read 29C0 ounces, «oí 0G0 ounces as stated. These errors cause much annoyance. Hie Miners’ Protective League have issued their prospectus.
The objects to be dealt with ntt, Hrst and principal question-Expulsion of the. Chinese. The League call upon men of c cry nation except Chinese to join their society. Repeal of the Gold Dut}-. Police protection, which they say is merely nominal at present.
Unlocking the public lands. Promulgation of the word of God throughout the mining districts of die colony.
Protection to native industry. Representation of mining interests, based on population. The men charged with the murderous assault luve been identified by one of the unfortunate mea as- saulted.
They are to be again brought up on Monday for further examination. Mr. Cowper has been well received by the miners. He drove out to Stoney Creek this afternoon, and con- versed with about 100 men.
It i« not known yet what action he will take on the Chinese matter. He told the miner« that the Government would protect them if they came back, but did not fully explain the ttept that would be taken.
The new rush at Stoney Creek is turning out well ; some of the surfacing work is giving very encourag- ing results.
About 250 diggers are now located on the new ground, and from 2 to 3 dwtt. ia being made in many instances. Another new rush has been made at Stoney Creek, but the tesult« are not so satisfactory. Flour ia selling at ¿¡25 per ton, and theie is a plen- tiful «upply. The population is »till increasing. Buildings of all »ize» are running up rapidly. “Weather delightful.. Heavy shower this morning. Plenty of water.
12th March 1861
Upon his arrival, the premier was presented with a petition from the chief organisers of the miners league committee.
He however refused to accept their legitimacy as spokesmen for the miners. All in all the exchange is a valuable reference as to the state of the agitators organisation at that time.
12th March 1861
The following is the address presented to the Hon. Charles Cowper at Burrangong ; also Mr. Cowper’s reply, which we take from Saturday’s Yass Courier :
“ Sir,-We, on behalf of the mining community of tlie Burrangong gold-fields congratulate ourselves on ha ving this opportunity of «resenting to vou this humbie petition.
“ We can assure you that nothing gives theater pleasure to the miners in goner al than to wekou.o you as first Minister of the Crown to this gold-field, knowing that your sound practical judgment in con- ducting the affairs of the country is sufficient guaran- tee for us that our local wants will not be overlooked by the Ministry of which you are a member.
‘ “ While we appreciate you as an able statesman and the leader of a liberal Government whose mea- sures have tended to benefit the colony at large, we hnte still greater obstacles in our path, which we trust you will see the necessity of removing.
“ You have now been an eyewitness to the orderly and peaceful state of society here, and must have seen enough to convince you that most of tne state- ments in the Sydney papers aro not only exaggerated, but utterly false.
“ We are fully convinced that the miners are the very_ last men in the colony to ‘resort to any extreme or violent measures in opposition to the law or the general wish of the Government, but at the same time we beg to submit to you that it is our firm and thorough conviction that their détermination to pre- vent the presence of Chinamen uponthese gold-fields is so strong and decided that it behoves the Govern- ment to adopt such measures as .will tend’to conciliate the diggers in order to avoid what would otherwise result m a dire calamity.
“ We are wishful to obtain from you some opinion of the intentions of the Government as regards the Chinese question, as at present, in consequence of the uncertainty which hangs over the matter, society here is kept in a state of doubt, uncertainty, and’anxiety.
“ In conclusion, we beg to repeat, in the event of the Chinamen having the encouragement or sanction of Government to return to Burrangong, the result v» ill be highly disastrous to the general community, and end in a collision in which human life will be destroyed.
‘ “ We therefore implore you, on the plea of humanity, to use all your valuable influence to avert so lamentable a catastrophe. “ We ore, Sir, your humble servants, (Signed) “ JOHN STEWART, HENRY DAYTON, CHARLES ALLEN, RICHARD GONION, WILLIAM SPICER, WILLIAM CARR. DONALD CAMERON.” ,
I [Mr. Cowper’s answer.] I “ Mr. Cowper acknowledges the receipt of a docu- ment, purporting to be a copy of an addtess intended tobe presented to him on behalf of the Burragong miners ; but while he is most anxions to place him- self, without delay, in communication with those of the mining body who am the friends of secial order, and who are not already committed to a course of proceedings which must be subversive of alhgood government, he docs not perceive in the address any allegation that the seven persons whose signatures are attached claim to speak, or have any authority to speak, on behalf of the miners of the Burragong gold- fields.
Four of the number are, however, recognised by him as the chief movers in the establishment of a league which has published and fully circulated a manifesto containing aspersions upon the Govern- ment which are palpably untrue, and in which lan guageis used, in reference to constituted authorities, of a very inflammatory character.
“Mr. Cowper, though grateful for the assurance that his presence among the miners is generally welcomed “by them, regrets to observe in the document ?which has just reached him some expressions of a similar tendency. He has undertaken the journey which has brought him here at a great sacrifice of personal convenience, and at considerable incon ttnifiice to the public business generally, for the sole purpose of enabling the Government to ascertain, in the most reliable manner, the precise state of matters at these diggings.
Mr. Cowper is therefore desirous of placing himself in free intercourse with the miners, that he may be mado peifectly acquainted with their wants, and thoroughly understand what their grie ranees ore. But he cannot accept any self constituted delegates as exponents of the views of the mining body ; and he wishes to be informed whether the gentlemen who have signed the document which has been transmitted to him have been duly authorised to speak for and act in behalf of the miners generally ; and if BO, in what manner and by what number of miners such authority was given. “Burrangong, 4th March, 1861.”
15th March 1861
The effect of Cowper’s visit became clearer in the wake of his returning to Sydney and the reports of his visit started to emerge.
In effect he staved off open rebellion against the Chinese being returned and the rule of law upheld by assuring the assembled crowds that he regarded “the Celestials as pests and he would use every effort to keep them away.”
This bought some breathing space, but it raised expectations that the government act on their behalf sooner rather than later.
15th March 1861
difficulties seen to be in a fair way of being all settled without bloodshed. The military aro on the ground and have, it is said, been well received.
Nay. it ia even asserted that the officers have dined with the diggers ; but the report of anything (under the circumstances) BO extraordi- nary requires confirmation.
lhe Premier has returned. He has succeeded in coaxing the miners into submission-at all events for a time.
He distinctly told thom, that the law would be upheld, and the Chinese at present in the country protected from aggression at any cost ; but he assured them, at the same time, that he and his colleagues re- garded the celestials as “ pests,” and would use every effort to keep them nway.
They (the miners) seemed satisfied with this pledge, and have not only passed a vote of confidence in the Ministry, but have given the Premier n dinner.
He, therefore, returns in triumph. But how will it be if the promises of Mr. Cowper lead to nothing definite ?
The bulk of the diggers have a notion that the Government is all powerful, and will clenr the whole of the Chinese off the gold- fields in a very short time.
Now, even if the bill of Mr. Lucas pass both Houses in its integrity, it will not have the effcot which the diggers axe looking for. Will the Government introduce a still more stringent measure for this purpose ?
And, if so, will Parliament adopt it ? It will be on the miners becoming aware that their expectations cannot be fulfilled, that there will be the greatest danger of an outbreak.
These doings at Burrangong will be rather expen- sive in any case. The coat has been estimated at £16,000 by the Ministry, but it may be rather more ere the affair is over.
Already is there one claim for compensation by a Chinaman, to the amount of £300, for property destroyed by the rioters. Other claims of like nature will come in, and we do not see how they can be evaded.
And there may be other riots. The miners are clamorous for, among other things, a repeal of the gold duty, but it will be found, we doubt not, that their own conduct has rendered this impossible. _ In the meantime, the voice of the Sydney mercan- tile interest has been raised, we are glad to say, in support of law, order, and honesty, both Houses of Parliament having been petitioned for justice to the Chinese.
Upon Premier Cowper’s return to Sydney legislation to restrict Chinese immigration by levying an entry tax was introduced and passed in the lower house Legislative Assembly.
This was mistakenly seen as being the end of the matter. As Gold Commissioners were issued with instructions to restrict Chinese to specified areas the very expensive military presence on the Lambing Flat field was withdrawn thus paving the way for a new round of violence to emerge.
24th May 1861
A chief problem lay in the fact that the Chinese were removed to their new mining zones even before the new legislation was enacted, and they were rightly angry at having their legitimate mining claims taken away from them without compensation.
As they set about working both within and without of their allotted areas, the departure of the troops left the field on a knife edge.
24th May 1861
I have just heard on good authority that the Military are to leave here on Friday.
I think the Government cannot be in possession of the state of this place, or at present they would not be removed. Since the rush to Tipperary Gully many parts of these fields have been comparatively deserted, and the Chinese are every day endeavouring to work at Spring and Stony Creeks, and other parts of these fields.
At Demondrill Creek, where there are a great number of Chinese, they openly refuse to carry out the Commissioner’s orders until the Chinese question relative to gold-fields is settled.
The presence of the military here is necessary. The country having incurred the expense of sending troops here, it is re- gretted they are to be removed before tho question is settled.
The force that will be left, after their departure, will be quite insufficient to maintain order in the event of a Chinese disturbance.
If the Chinese in this district pursue their present course, and the military leave, it will inevitably tend to a roll up. <
31st May 1861
As the military departed in late May the correspondent for the Herald noted that in relation to the Chinese question “if the Chinese were allowed to work on Spring and Stoney Creeks, now comparatively deserted, and from which they were expelled, and never reinstated, as many in Sydney have been given to understand, our yield of gold would be increased by one thousand ounces every week.”
31st May 1861
At about six o’clock on Friday morning (Queen’s birthday), the boom of the Artillery announced their departure-a salute of twenty-one guns was fired, which made every house in the town sliake, and then immediately started for Sydney, via Yass and Goulburn.
The detachment” of the 12th started about, eleven o’clock, and whatever. .opinions may be held as to the necessity of their ‘ presence here, their departure is- regretted by all. The absence of the red coats amongst the motley crowd of. diggers with whom they used to enjoy their . nobblers-no -artillery men parading with guns, or breaking in horses-no officers riding about, make3 this place appear for the present duli.
Both officers and men take with them the best wishes of all classes, and sorry as we are to part with them, we yet hope their presence in these parts will never again bo re- quired to uphold law and order.
I noticed in town yesterday more Chinese than I have seen for a long time. I also noticed one crowd of intelligent men amusing themselves by throwing rubbish at them.
“Without entering into the Chinese question I may state that if the Chinese were allowed to work on Spring and Stoney Creoles, now com- paratively deserted, and”from which -they-were expelled, and never reinstated, as many in Sydney have been given to understand, our yield of gold would be increased by one thousand- ounce« every week.
“Whether this is of any importance or any loes to the colony, I leave others to judge. Several accidents have again happened- this ‘ week ; one fatal.
A man, named Dominic Parry, waa working at his claim a few nights since, near Golden Point, Spring Creek, with, bia mate -it was very wet ground, and they had to work day’ and night. Parry, in tilting a bucket, jammed his hand, and exclaimed, “Oh, I have hurt my finger,” and placed his head upon the roller of the windlass, his mate supposes he must have fainted, for, almost im- mediately, ho slipped, legs first down the shaft, thirty-two feet in depth.
It being slabbed, some of the pegs projected-his head came in contact with them, cawing a fearful fracture, and almost instant death.
Another sudden death also occurred at Stoney Creek. Catherine Bradley, a native of Hull, about twenty.four years of age, married about seven years. For two or three days she had been very, intemperate.
Some time during the night of Friday last her hus- band noticed her get out of bed to get a drink of tea from a *’ billy “ that stood in the place ; before she could raise it to her lips she fell and expired. Magis- terial enquiries have been held in both cases, and ver- I diets in accordance with the facts given.
I would here call attention to the necessity of a coroner being appointed to this district j. not that I wish-for one moment to cast any discredit or find fault ‘ with these magisterial enquiries-they are conducted with every cure Bnd attention ; only too often inter feting with commissioners’ duties ;. and many here think’ that these deaths ought to be enquired into before a jury, and the fullest facts elicited ; the magia trates, I believe, having no power to summon a jury. <
21st June 1861
Speaking of ounces of gold per week – just what was the significance of the Burrangong field at that time in the overall pantheon of the NSW fields? A call of the card from this time shows just how important Lambing Flat was for gold mining in NSW at that time. It also provides crucial details of a battle between the Chinese and Europeans at Native Dog Creek close by the Lambing Flat field, where the Chinese successfully defended themselves against a small mob of miners seeking to drive them off their claims.
21st June 1861
With tensions on the field barely contained, the occasion of Chinese miners successfully defending their claims against attack at the nearby Native Dog Creek, escalated the sense of anger at the ‘Celestials’.
2nd July 1861
On Sunday 30 June, the long threatened ‘roll up’ occurred that brutally drove the Chinese off the field from their camps in Blackguard Gully and Back Creek A first hand account of events was delivered by the Herald correspondent writing at 11pm that same night. At the very time these words were being penned the brutalised Chinese were once again on a long trudge seeking refuge on a cold wet winters night at James Roberts’ Currawong Station some 20km away.
2nd July 1861
6th July 1861
Several days later and additional accounts were received by mail and published in the papers. Amongst the descriptions of the affray, calls for a strong response sounded out. As the writer here notes – “If the Government do not attempt to bring some of the parties engaged in this last riot to justice, no man’s life on any of the gold-fields will be safe.”
6th July 1861
9th July 1861
Amongst these accounts one record of enormous importance stands out. It is a letter from the Chinese to the NSW Governor outlining the extent of the grievances visited upon them at Lambing Flat over the course of that year up to and including the most recent riot.
9th July 1861
20th July 1861
Several weeks later the Herald correspondent returned to the events surrounding the riot of 30 June in a most comprehensive summary.
20th July 1861
Devastating though the events of 30 June were for the Chinese, it is the affray that came along afterwards that actually proved more shocking to those with political authority.
20th July 1861
Along with the return of the military to the field came the erstwhile reporter for the Sydney Morning Herald who had beaten a strategic departure along with the police after the miners assalt on the lockup. His even handed reporting of events had seen him pegged as a Chinese sympathiser – not a good tag to wear with no police presence on the field. His authorative account of the second riot complements his earlier work.
20th July 1861
With order re-established on the field, the public attention then shifted to State Parliament in Sydney.
26th November 1861
The new Chinese Immigration Act was assented to on 22 November 1861.
26th November 1861
4. Before any ol such Chinese shall be permitted to . land and before making any entry the master shall pay.’to such Collector or other proper officer ten -pounds for every such Chinese and no entry shall be deemed, to have been legally made or to have any legal effect until such payment Bhall have been made
And if any master shall neglect to pay any such sum or sholl land or permit to land any Chinese at any place ia the Colony before such sum shall have been paid for or by him with tho intent in any of the above cases of evading the payment thereof such master shall he liable for every such offence to a penalty not exceeding twenty pounds for each Chinese so landed «r permitted to land in addition to the amount of such sum
And in every such case in addition to any such penalty the vessel shall be forfeited and may be seized -condemned and disposed of in like manner as shipB forfeited for a breach of any law relating to the Cus- toms oí this Colony. ‘ ‘ like com for Chinese arriving othoiwise. o.
Every Chinese arriving in the Colony after the passing of this Act otherwise than by any vessel shall pay or have paid for him to some officer whom the Ooveraor with the advice of the Executive Council may appoint at any places on or near the borders of the colony or otherwise conveniently situate for that purpose a like sum of ten pounds. ?
Ctrtifieates of turn paul to be given to Chínete and to be evidence.
C. The Cellcctor or other officer as aforesaid receiv- ing suchsum from or for any Chinese shall without de- mand forthwith supply himwith a certificate in writing under his hand of the payment of such sum such certi- ficate to be in a form to be settled by the regulations hereinafter mentioned And Buch certificate whenso- ever and wheresoever produced by such Chinese shall be conclusive evidence «n behalf of himself and of any other person who may have paid such sum for him that such sum has been duly paid. Pajuienta aforesaid to be paid into Contohdated Fond.
7. All sums as aforesaid so paid by or on behalf of any Chinese shall be paid over to the Colonial Trea- surer and be by him carried to the Consolidated Re- venue Fund of the Colony. Certificate of exemption fiom payment.
S. All Chinese within the Colony of New South Wales shall on or before the twenty-eighth day of Pebiuary one thousand eight hundred and sixty-two apply to the nearest Clerk of Petty Sessions or Gold Commissioner fox a-Certificate and sttcn Clerk of-Petty j Sessions .or Gold Commissioner shall deliver to any | Chinese so applying a parchment certificate which shall bear on the face of it the name of the Chinaman applying and the signature of the Clerk of Petty Sessions or Gold Commissioner granting such certi- ficate and all other matters which the Government may deem necessary and the holder of such certificate shall be exempted from payments under this Act. Chinese not to be naturalized.
9. The certificate mentioned in the sixth section of the Act of Council eleventh Victoria number thirty- nine shall not hereafter be issued or granted to any Chinese. – – Tensity on not paying or having,had paid fee for entrance to the Colony.
10. If any Chinese shall enter or attempt to enter the Colony without paying or having paid tor him the sum of ten pounds aforesaid he shall besides such sum be liable to a penalty not exceeding ten pounds and may be apprehended and taken before any Justice of the Peace most conveniently situated for “the purpose .who may take sufficient bail lor his appearance at the next Court of Petty Sessions or remand him to such Court as to such Justice shall seem fit uniese and until such Chinese shall produce a certificate of payment as aforesaid. Governor may remit penalties, Se.
11. It shall be lawful for the Governor -with the advice aforesaid to remit the whole or any part oí any penalty or sum of whatever description “due or pav ubJe or any forfeiture under this Act. Justice» may fix time to pay penalties.
12. ‘Upon the conviction ol any Chinese under this Act whereby he may be awarded to pay a sum of money it ahall be lawful for the Justice if he shall see fit to order that such sumfor any part thereof shall be payable at some future day not being longer than two months from the date of such order provided security by way of recognisance to Her Majesty to the satis- faction of such Justice be given for the payment of the amount mentioned in and at the time fixed by any euch order. Penalties recovered in a enmmaiy manner.
13. All penalties and sums payable under this Aot may be recovered in a summary manner before any ‘two _ Justices of the Peace And at the hearing such Justices may decide upon their own view and judg- ment -whether any person charged before them is a Chinese -within the meaning of this Act. Short Title and commencement. U. This Act shall be styled and may be cited as the “ Chinese Immigrants Regulation and Restriction Act of 1861” and shall commence and come into «Deration on and from the twentv-eighth day of 1-ebruary one thousand eight hundred and eixty-two.
The aftermath
Basically it was a case that if no one else wanted it – then Chinese could work it.
This in itself was not devoid of opportunity for those who remained to work the fields rather than either depart for new diggings elsewhere around the world or indeed head home to China.
Even so called worked out portions of the fields, were often still very rich in gold for those with the skill in separating it out from the mass of earth that surrounded it.
This largely spelled the end of hostilities for most of the diggings – except for Lambing Flat / Burrangong. Passions here ran very deep and issues continuing to simmer for at least the next five years without however revisiting violent conflicts.